IEEE (The Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers) has started a public video section on its web site it calls ieee.tv. I have been a member of IEEE since at least my graduate school days, as are many speech and forensic scientists, so if you are in either one or both of these fields and are not a member, I highly recommend that you check into it. (And in the spirit of full disclosure and in the hopes of avoiding investigation under who knows what new law is actually now or ever will be on the books about such things on the Internet - no, they didn't pay me to plug them as a professional organization!).
On to the subject of this post: ieee.tv has a fascinating video clip on the gunshot analysis performed by various experts on the recordings JFK assassination.
Hat Tip: Thanks Alex!
Showing posts with label evidence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label evidence. Show all posts
Tuesday, November 24, 2009
Friday, October 23, 2009
Audio Forensics: Speech quality versus intelligibility
Engineering Technology Magazine (Institute of Engineering and Technology, UK) has a well written article concerning research by CLEAR (Center for Law Enforcement Audio Research) concerning the effect of noise reduction on intelligibility of evidentiary recordings and other audio in law enforcement situations.
... most speech-enhancement techniques improve sound quality at the expense of intelligibility, particularly when the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) is very low. Closely related as they are, speech quality and intelligibility are not identical.
This is a classic trap that is easy for a novice to fall into.
Read it all.
(Hat tip: RH)
Labels:
audio,
audio forensics,
evidence,
filtering,
human auditory system
Thursday, February 19, 2009
Forensics: US National Academy of Sciences report is released
DNA evidence was the pebble in the pond, so to speak, for elevating the "science" in "forensic science" - the scientific rigor that has accompanied this new discipline of forensic science continues to ripple through all of the forensic disciplines and our legal system. Of course, DNA evidence was not the only motivating factor, but I do contend that it was the most significant and that the mindset that accompanied its introduction also carried over the other disciplines.
The latest ripple was the release yesterday of a report by the US National Academy of Sciences titled "Strengthening Forensic Science in the United States: A Path Forward". You can read it online or pre-order a print copy at this link.
One should keep in mind while listening to or reading press accounts of this report something that Robert Mueller (physicist, USA) once said, and I'll paraphrase: "Everything reported in broadcast or print media is generally correct, except, that is, for what they report on things that you are actually well versed in, which they invariably get wrong." Such will likely be the case with reporting on this subject.
That being said, how I am interpreting the early press accounts of the report is that this report is another step in this process of bringing the scientific rigor applied to the introduction of DNA evidence into our legal system to all of the disciplines that were already here. In my opinion, this is a worthwhile endeavor. However, we must all be wise enough to understand that we are humans and that any system we create will not be perfect, but if we design the system correctly then mechanisms will be included to minimize and weed out these natural errors while also minimizing the adverse affects on the ability of the system to perform its intended purpose.
Tuesday, January 27, 2009
Evidence: Listen to the raw audio evidence
If you would care to listen to the audio and read the transcripts of the Governor Blagojevich (IL, USA) wiretaps, here is the link.
Labels:
audio forensics,
evidence,
legal,
surveillance
Saturday, January 17, 2009
Legal: Recording conversations in the USA
Michael Flynn's podcast, Legal Lad's Quick and Dirty Tips for a More Lawful Life, gives an excellent overview of the legalities of making an audio recording of someone in the USA when you are not a government agency performing lawful surveillance. When is it legal and when is it not? The short answer is: it depends - on whether there was a reasonable expectation of privacy, what state the conversation takes place in, and whether all parties being recorded gave consent.
For instance, if one is having a loud conversation on the street (a public place), how can one expect privacy from being overheard? If one can be overheard, how can he then complain that a record (or recording) was made of what he said? An example from daily life, that we can all probably identify with, is the standard phrase we hear when we dial technical support or customer service - "All calls are recorded for quality assurance." In other words - "We're recording you - you've been warned". By being advised and not hanging up, you will likely been seen as having given implied consent.
Legal Lad, being a lawyer as well as having good communication skills, gives a more thorough and educational overview of this subject.
Enjoy!
For instance, if one is having a loud conversation on the street (a public place), how can one expect privacy from being overheard? If one can be overheard, how can he then complain that a record (or recording) was made of what he said? An example from daily life, that we can all probably identify with, is the standard phrase we hear when we dial technical support or customer service - "All calls are recorded for quality assurance." In other words - "We're recording you - you've been warned". By being advised and not hanging up, you will likely been seen as having given implied consent.
Legal Lad, being a lawyer as well as having good communication skills, gives a more thorough and educational overview of this subject.
Enjoy!
Labels:
audio,
evidence,
legal,
recording,
surveillance
Tuesday, December 23, 2008
Image Forensics: An interview with Hany Farid
SiliconValley has an interview with image forensics researcher Hany Farid. My favorite excerpt was this:
Enjoy!
Of course, susceptibility to tampering is not the only thing to be considered when evaluating the relative merits of digital imagery as evidence, but it is obvious that tampering with a digital copy is easier to do and (possibly) get away with than tampering with film or tape.Farid first conceived of the possibilities of digital forensics while at MIT, waiting in the checkout line at the library. Restless, he picked up a copy of the Federal Rules of Evidence, then started randomly reading. What he saw startled him: Film and digital images were equivalent evidence, in the eyes of the court.
"This just seemed like a bad idea,'' he said. "Not that I'm good at seeing the future — but I could tell this would be a problem."
Enjoy!
Labels:
evidence,
image forensics,
legal,
video
Sunday, December 14, 2008
CSI: TV show highlights new fingerprint technology
WLFI Television (Indiana, USA) did a piece about the television show CSI spotlighting a new fingerprint technology developed by Purdue University. The piece says that it was supposed to air last month. Neither the researchers who developed the technology (led by Professor Graham Cooks) nor the company that now owns it (Prosolia Incorporated) saw the script in advance, so there is no telling whether it was accurately represented.
If any of you readers did see the episode and would like to fill us in, please do!
If any of you readers did see the episode and would like to fill us in, please do!
Sunday, November 23, 2008
Biometrics: Request for automation to reduce FBI backlog
The StrategyPage has a short article on the backlog facing the FBI in analyzing DNA samples - 40,000 samples in the que with a work-off rate of 4 samples per week! Automation will reportedly improve the work-off rate to 200 samples per week.
One data point that would be useful in getting a fuller picture would be the rate that new samples are being added to the que. If anyone has any information on that, please post it in the comments.
The article also gives a brief history of biometrics, starting with appearance (visual) and going through fingerprints (first recognized as unique 4 centuries ago!) and others until the recent methods of gait and DNA.
Enjoy!
One data point that would be useful in getting a fuller picture would be the rate that new samples are being added to the que. If anyone has any information on that, please post it in the comments.
The article also gives a brief history of biometrics, starting with appearance (visual) and going through fingerprints (first recognized as unique 4 centuries ago!) and others until the recent methods of gait and DNA.
Enjoy!
Friday, September 26, 2008
Evidence: Study of the impact of CSI-style shows on jurors
An overview of the study by researchers at the University of Leicester can be found at Science Daily.
Labels:
brain science,
csi effect,
evidence,
legal,
testimony
Wednesday, September 24, 2008
Testimony: Memory is fallible, study confirms
Cosmos (Australian, popular-science magazine) has an article on research by James Ost, University of Portsmouth (UK) into the accuracy of recall, in this case, of video news reports seen some three months prior. There were a couple of interesting statements that popped out at me:
"Ost said that people who were more likely to come up with false memories scored higher on a scale of "fantasy proneness" than those that did not." (My comment - "fantasy proneness" appears to mean "creative" in this context.)Although the article doesn't address it directly, previous studies have shown that accuracy of recall also depends greatly on the amount of time that has past since the event, which gives all the more reason to get witness statements soonest.
"Ost said that when DNA testing became available in the U.S. in the early 90s, 80 per cent of death row cases that were exonerated, were found to have been wrongly convicted on the strength of mistaken identity."
Labels:
brain science,
evidence,
legal,
testimony
Tuesday, September 16, 2008
Linguistics: Forensic Linguistics used on text message evidence
Dr Tim Grant, Deputy Director of the Centre for Forensic Linguistics at Aston University (UK), is well known in forensic linguistic circles. ScienceDaily has excerpts from an interview with Dr. Grant following the successful conviction of a murderer that relied partly on Dr. Grant's testimony about text messages allegedly sent by the suspect (since convicted) to throw investigators off the trail. I call your attention to the careful and correct use of the phrases "unlikely" and "more likely" to describe the results of the analysis, instead of a phrase such as "proved conclusively".
In addition, here is a link to a BBC (British Broadcasting Corporation, UK) news story about the case and the analysis of the text message evidence. Very interesting stuff!
In addition, here is a link to a BBC (British Broadcasting Corporation, UK) news story about the case and the analysis of the text message evidence. Very interesting stuff!
Labels:
audio,
audio forensics,
evidence,
legal,
linguistics
Thursday, July 24, 2008
Biometrics: Fingerprints versus palm prints
While driving back from Charleston, SC (USA) today - a lovely seaport city, by the way - I was catching up on my podcasts and happened to listen to a Wall Street Journal (US, center-right, business news) segment on new palm print readers. The part that caught my attention was the claim by one interviewee that - and I'm paraphrasing here - "people" were concerned about using fingerprint biometric identification technologies because they were worried about later being falsely accused of a crime due to a mistaken match to a print left at a crime scene. The interviewee went on to say that as police did not collect palm prints during crime scene investigations, palm print biometrics systems were getting a leg up in the market place.
This made me wonder exactly who are these "people" he referred to? I'm rather doubtful that it is the general public that has these concerns. I find it much easier to believe that elements of criminal "society" or privacy advocates would be tuned-in to these issues, but not the average man on the street. I might be being too critical of this particular piece, but I thought that the reporter should have challenged, or at least followed up on, that statement.
In a larger context, this may unfortunately be a textbook example of how public policy is determined at the chaotic intersection where the general public, subject matter experts, issue advocates, the marketplace, and technology all collide. I certainly hope not!
Labels:
biometrics,
crime scene investigation,
evidence
Sunday, May 11, 2008
Human Auditory System: Voice Risk Analysis
The Economist (UK, center-left economics and news magazine) has a short article in the May 8th, 2008 edition on Voice Risk Analysis, which is another name for Voice Stress Analysis or Micro-Stress Analysis. You might recall from my previous posts (here and here) on this topic that I believe voice stress analysis to be a workable interrogation tool, when correctly administered, but then, so again can the copy machine in the hallway - it all depends on whether the subject is, or can be made to be, concerned about it. It is not, however, a lie detector. This author of the Economist's article seems to have come to a similar conclusion.
An interesting point in the article is that, at least in one real-world deployment of a commercial system, the biggest benefit was gained from simply telling the claimants that such a system would be used on them - which caused many to drop their claims prior to being "analyzed" by the system.
An interesting point in the article is that, at least in one real-world deployment of a commercial system, the biggest benefit was gained from simply telling the claimants that such a system would be used on them - which caused many to drop their claims prior to being "analyzed" by the system.
Friday, February 29, 2008
Forensics: Track where someone has been by analyzing their hair
The Economist magazine (UK) has a short article on how forensic analysis of the chemical composition of a suspect's hair can be used to determine where he has been.
Tuesday, June 05, 2007
Evidence: Courts feeling their ways through electronic discovery issues
The Economist (UK news and economics magazine; liberal in the classic sense) reports on how the judicial system is learning to deal with discovering evidence on mobile phones, computers, and other digital devices.
Labels:
computer forensics,
evidence,
legal,
phone forensics
Friday, May 11, 2007
Phone Forensics: Cell/Mobile Phone Forensics Recognized for What It Is
Wired has an article on Cell Phone ("Mobile Phone" for those unfamiliar with US English) Forensics that comes across as critical in tone, but, in my humble opinion, simply conveys the message that there is nothing magic about cell phone forensics - it is evidence and should be treated as such. That means establishing the chain of custody to preserve it and protect it from intentional and unintentional tampering.
The article makes a point about some software tools not having tamper protection built in. I know that this is a current issue regarding evidence, particularly digital evidence. However, the drive to ideally preserve evidence can be taken too far - real world practicalities must also be acknowledged and accommodated or else the evidential system, and therefore justice, will suffer in the end.
Phone forensics is a helpful tool and can provide valuable clues that would not be otherwise available. But like all scientific evidence, it must be handled, analyzed, and presented properly, and then taken into account along with other evidence, to be of use to investigators and the court.
The article makes a point about some software tools not having tamper protection built in. I know that this is a current issue regarding evidence, particularly digital evidence. However, the drive to ideally preserve evidence can be taken too far - real world practicalities must also be acknowledged and accommodated or else the evidential system, and therefore justice, will suffer in the end.
Aside: Please do not mistake my point - I am not against establishing standard operating procedures and best practices for preserving evidence, performing examinations, and the like. What I am against is establishing overly idealistic expectations that are not achievable in the real world across the myriad law enforcement and justice agencies. Put another way, I am for a reasonable balance that is biased toward continually improving the system over time.To return to the main thrust of this post, cell phone data is not just any run of the mill evidence, it is "scientific evidence", so someone acting as an examiner needs to recover and analyze the data and then present the results. The article helpfully provides a link to a draft NIST (The National Institute of Standards and Technology, a US government agency) recommendation titled Guidelines on Cell Phone Forensics.
The Wired article, at least to my reading, gives the impression that if a tool does not have built-in digital signature protection that it is somehow completely suspect. I don't think that is the case. There are ways to adjust operating procedures to accommodate this, such as MD5 hash generation software routines and proper (in the British sense of the word) evidence handling procedures. I think it is a good idea to have protection built-in, but that it is likewise a bad idea to automatically assume that if a tool that is used in an investigation doesn't have digital signature features built in that the evidence was likely tampered with. That sounds blindingly obvious when approached in this manner, but may not be so obvious to a jury or the general public.
Phone forensics is a helpful tool and can provide valuable clues that would not be otherwise available. But like all scientific evidence, it must be handled, analyzed, and presented properly, and then taken into account along with other evidence, to be of use to investigators and the court.
Thursday, May 03, 2007
Computer Audio and Video: Codec packs
Being able to play audio and video files, often years after they were originally created, has been a steadily growing problem for audio, video, and computer forensic examiners.
Of course, video examiners encounter this almost daily if they are dealing with security digital video recorder (DVR) files because of the proprietary codecs (which is short for COder DECoder, and is the software program that converts video to and from a particular digital file format) used by manufacturers of the systems to lock users into their brands.
Even for those who do not process security DVR every day, things have been getting worse. Part of this is due to changes in the latest Windows Media Player where Microsoft removed one of the popular codecs previously used to encode/decode AVI files. Many people are under the impression that AVI is uncompressed and either doesn't need a codec or only has one universal codec. This is far from the truth. AVI, like WAV, is a very flexible format and it supports the use of almost any audio or video codec. To play the file, you have to have the correct codec - period. No codec, no playback - it is that simple.
I was faced with this problem just recently due to the Microsoft changes. The files were uncompressed AVI and would not play on three different machines, even though they played back correctly only two months before. A bit of digging found the cause. The solution ended up being to download an audio/video codec pack. I used the free one found here, but there are others out on the Internet also.
You can imagine how this can be a problem for law enforcement where evidence may need to be archived for up to 25 years and still be able to played back. All it takes is one automatic update and the ability to playback can cease. This is why I recommend to my students that they always include a copy of a freeware player that will play back the media as part of the archived evidence.
Of course, video examiners encounter this almost daily if they are dealing with security digital video recorder (DVR) files because of the proprietary codecs (which is short for COder DECoder, and is the software program that converts video to and from a particular digital file format) used by manufacturers of the systems to lock users into their brands.
Even for those who do not process security DVR every day, things have been getting worse. Part of this is due to changes in the latest Windows Media Player where Microsoft removed one of the popular codecs previously used to encode/decode AVI files. Many people are under the impression that AVI is uncompressed and either doesn't need a codec or only has one universal codec. This is far from the truth. AVI, like WAV, is a very flexible format and it supports the use of almost any audio or video codec. To play the file, you have to have the correct codec - period. No codec, no playback - it is that simple.
I was faced with this problem just recently due to the Microsoft changes. The files were uncompressed AVI and would not play on three different machines, even though they played back correctly only two months before. A bit of digging found the cause. The solution ended up being to download an audio/video codec pack. I used the free one found here, but there are others out on the Internet also.
You can imagine how this can be a problem for law enforcement where evidence may need to be archived for up to 25 years and still be able to played back. All it takes is one automatic update and the ability to playback can cease. This is why I recommend to my students that they always include a copy of a freeware player that will play back the media as part of the archived evidence.
Labels:
computer audio,
computer forensics,
computer video,
evidence
Sunday, April 29, 2007
Evidence: New procedure to improve accuracy of witness recollections
BBC Focus Magazine has an article about a technique, called self-administered interview (SAI), that is said to improve the accuracy of witness recall by 42 percent.
Under current UK police procedure, there is apparently a two step process for interviewing a witness - first a brief (summary) interview and then a more detailed one. The proposed procedure instead makes the initial process much more intensive and has the witness record as many details as possible using a questionnaire. The work is by Dr Lorraine Hope (University of Portsmouth, UK) and other researchers at University of Abertay and Florida International University.
In contrast to what the current common perception of what crime scene investigation can accomplish is, in reality there are a large number of crimes where the crucial evidence is testimony by an eye, or ear, witness. This makes accurate recollection extremely important, particularly since detailed memory does degrade rapidly with time in most people and eye/ear witness testimony, as currently "managed", is at least occasionally later found to be erroneous.
Additional Link: The Daily Telegraph (UK, center-right newspaper) also has a write-up with a few more details.
Under current UK police procedure, there is apparently a two step process for interviewing a witness - first a brief (summary) interview and then a more detailed one. The proposed procedure instead makes the initial process much more intensive and has the witness record as many details as possible using a questionnaire. The work is by Dr Lorraine Hope (University of Portsmouth, UK) and other researchers at University of Abertay and Florida International University.
In contrast to what the current common perception of what crime scene investigation can accomplish is, in reality there are a large number of crimes where the crucial evidence is testimony by an eye, or ear, witness. This makes accurate recollection extremely important, particularly since detailed memory does degrade rapidly with time in most people and eye/ear witness testimony, as currently "managed", is at least occasionally later found to be erroneous.
Additional Link: The Daily Telegraph (UK, center-right newspaper) also has a write-up with a few more details.
Labels:
evidence,
eye witness,
memory,
testimony
Sunday, March 18, 2007
Courtroom: Accreditation of Forensic Expert Witnesses & Daubert in UK
The issues of introducing accreditation for forensic expert witnesses and Daubert hearings have again been raised in the UK, this time in response to recent acquittals (where both sides had expert witnesses that disagreed) and the conviction of Gene Morrison on 20 counts of deceptively representing himself as a forensic expert with academic qualifications.
Several interesting things are discussed in this article (which basically reads like an opinion piece), including Daubert, whether a case should proceed when there is a serious dispute over forensic evidence, registration and accreditation of forensic expert witnesses, and the effect of privatizing forensic science service organizations.
(Hat Tip: TimesOnline, UK)
Several interesting things are discussed in this article (which basically reads like an opinion piece), including Daubert, whether a case should proceed when there is a serious dispute over forensic evidence, registration and accreditation of forensic expert witnesses, and the effect of privatizing forensic science service organizations.
(Hat Tip: TimesOnline, UK)
Labels:
accreditation,
courtroom,
daubert,
evidence,
expert witness,
forensic,
legal
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
